• tal@lemmy.today
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    10 months ago

    So what’s the best solution? You might think switching to an electric vehicle is the natural step. In fact, for short trips, an electric bike or moped might be better for you—and for the planet.

    However, in an enclosed EV, you aren’t out in the weather.

    I’ve spent time bike-commuting, and I live somewhere where the weather is pretty mild. But there’s a pretty big difference between being out in the wet and wind and cold when it’s raining or whatnot and being inside a dry, air-conditioned or heated cabin.

    But it’s more than that—they are actually displacing four times as much demand for oil as all the world’s electric cars at present, due to their staggering uptake in China and other nations where mopeds are a common form of transport.

    I mean, that’s fine, but as the article points out, that’s because China’s consumers are generally more price-sensitive and the likely alternative is a moped. If you’re gonna get a gasoline-powered moped or an electric bicycle, sure, unless the range is an issue, the e-bike is a pretty reasonable drop-in replacement.

    But people in the US don’t generally commute via gasoline-powered moped. That is, they’ve already made a judgement as to the tradeoffs, and I strongly doubt that whether-or-not the vehicle has an electric or gasoline motor is going to change this.

    https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publications/2021/acs/acs-48.pdf

    I don’t know which category a moped fits into here, but looking at Table 1 on Page 2, I assume that it’d be one of the following groups:

    • 0.1% of Americans commute via motorcycle.

    • 0.5% of Americans commute via bicycle.

    • 1.0% of Americans use “other means”.

    Compare to:

    • 84.8% use a car, truck, or van

    • 5.0% use public transportation

    I don’t think that introducing electric motors into the mix is going to be the factor that drastically changes the above ratios.