Should I take fingerprint logins off all my apps ? Obviously theyre easier to get in(bonk with hammer, take my hand and open it) but I’m not super concerned about a nearby threat.
i love how this thread are filled with degenerates the further you scroll
yes
Generally your password or code is considered private speech and so you can’t be compelled to give it under duress. Biometric authentication is considered public information and has no such protection.
Read: the police can’t make you enter a password but they can legally press your finger on the reader or hold your phone up to your face so it unlocks from facial recognition.
I do not think that is true anymore, especially at the borders.
Yeah within 50 miles of a border or us entry point they have different laws.
But with biometrics you don’t even have the option of not complying and falling back on your devices physical security while you wait for your lawyer.
I don’t use them for device unlock, but I use them for app unlock.
We don’t know your threat model nor your legal jurisdiction, so we couldn’t really say. And for OPSEC reasons, it may be better to not tell us your location.
Moon, dark side
your biometrics are a password you cannot change. if they leak, you’re fucked.
Biometrics arent used as passwords … they are hashed on one particular device and not usually used outside of a single devices context.
For are save enough for everyday use.
Will they make things easier for some actors…yes… but if you are targeted by them you are fucked anyway
The device hashes leaking isn’t the risk, it’s someone getting a high quality image of your fingerprint itself. With that they can create something to pass the hashes.
Though you could probably move on to new fingers if they only got one of them from a compromised device. So you can change your finger password, but only 9 times.
If someone has the ability to hack into your device so deeply… any other method is compromised too.
Which is way … fingerprints sensor are good enough safety.
For personal use anyway
If you use a fingerprint reader for access (say at work), you’re fingerprinted for some reason, or even just post a high enough resolution picture of your fingers it could be defeated.
They’re fine. Most people aren’t being attacked by people who are going to make a fake finger. But phones aren’t the only vector for compromise.
obviously they aren’t literal passwords…
No…they are only used in a local context… In terms of safety they are ok… of course law enforcement can simply point you mobile at your face to unlock it but thats about it.
Disclaimer: NSFW
Regarding fingerprint sensors, most humans have 20 digits to choose from for finger/toe prints. 21 if you’re a guy…
Yes, I have actually successfully tested exactly that, using my dickprint as a fingerprint! Good luck getting my device unlocked mofos!
Addendum to that, you gotta get me hard first…
When just unlocking your phone in public gets you a fine for indecent exposure…
Plot of an early 2000s Oceans Eleven porn parody right here.
Ocean’s Eleven Inches
I bet a clit print would work too. And nipple prints.
I guess maybe there’s A cop that can find the clit, but gonna be hard to find.
There are a few lady cops. They also don’t care about pleasing their partners, but they have their own parts.
butthole
Instructions unclear, phone stuck in ass, plz send halp…
safe and warm, all is well.
But is it unlocked or not?
It’s been unlocked for like 3 hours, I think it recognized my hemorrhoids.
That’s why I need help, it won’t come out until I lock it again…
Someone mentioned nipple prints and even nose prints when I first posted my experimental findings, so yeah those probably work…
Clit print? Well I don’t have a clitoris available to test that idea, but feel free to let us know your findings, I’m sure the ladies of the Fediverse would like to know…
If you’re not super concerned then you kind of answer your own question.
If somebody hits you over the head with a hammer, breaking into your phone is also more of a secondary concern.
I use it for phone unlocking but not for my password vault.
I’m sure this is highly location dependent, but biometrics can be used by law enforcement to access your devices without your collaboration. You cannot be compelled to give up a password (though potentially you could be held in contempt for refusing to disclose if you are court ordered).
As always, though, the best practices are ones that are sustainable and depend on your personal threat model. An app that’s locked by a biometric each time you access it is a lot more secure than an app that stays logged in.
I’d like to know from a legal expert, what case or precedent was set in the US that allows LEOs to coerce biometrics, but excludes passwords.
The law isn’t entirely settled and there are conflicting rulings in different jurisdictions. Legal Eagle gets into it in the context of the Atlanta Forest Defender that wiped his phone instead of unlocking of for a border agent a few months who, but the basics is that your password (testimonial evidence, ie the contents of your mind) are legally protected under the Fourth and/or Fifth Amendment, whereas holding a phone up to your face or compelling a fingerprint are physical acts and not necessarily testimonial.
Not a lawyer, but the American Bar Association has a whole article on it that’s worth a read.
tl;dr: It’s complicated.
Not a legal expert, but in the basic case it’s pretty straightforward. The US Constitution’s Fifth Amendment gives the right not to testify against yourself if you’re suspected of a crime. And since the only way they can get a password in your head is through speech, you don’t have to say anything (the “right to remain silent” in cop shows).
The Fourth Amendment gives rights against searches and seizures, but it can be overridden by a warrant and has been further eroded by exceptions over time. So in effect once you’re in custody they can manhandle you into looking at your phone or putting your thumb on it.
Also there’s just the reality of it being easier to not say something than guarantee your thumb doesn’t touch your phone with outside help. You might be able to get the latter thrown out in court, but that’s an after the fact remedy.
When attending any sort of anti establishment events such as study circles, protests, demonstrations, manifestations or campaigns that the ruling class define as disorderly or whatever, I turn biometrics off at the very least. I have blocked internet access to the biometrics package on my phone (Android, Samsung), so I’m not worried about it being collected. For logins/logons that I feel need 2FA, I use a physical passkey.
For sure in that instance dont use biometrics.
With high res cameras everywhere these days, shoulder-surfing is a realistic threat vector, and using biometrics is actually part of the mitigation.
What’s the concern? The main issue with using biometrics is a person can force you to put your finger on the sensor or with face unlock can hold up the screen to your face (or some crappy tech just needs a picture of you).
The fingerprint isn’t stored remotely, it’s used to generate authenticate to the app, not the account. That’s why you have to log in to the app the first time.
Tech varies but at a high level that login returns a key that’s stored in a secure storage built in to the hardware on the device. It would be extremely difficult to intercept that key exchange or to access the key, even with longterm physical access to the device. This key is then and used to generate authentication tokens when you open the app. The key itself never leaves the device and typically isn’t even stored at the remote server, only another “public key” that can be used to validate the tokens are genuine but can’t be realistically used to reverse engineer a valid token much less the “private key” stored on your device.
Of course it’s theoretically possible to reverse engineer a key or token, but as long as they use modern cryptographic standards given the current level of technology it would take the combined computing power of the world a very long time to do that for a single user. It is way easier to just guess or even brute force your password, which you should change periodically and should be long and complex enough and not reused to be hard to brute force or guess.
I suppose there’s also some small risk that a hardware manufacturer (or their compromised LLMs acting as firmware coders) may build in a back door to their biometrics or a government may build in a back door to a new cryptographic standard that isn’t well known and force companies to use it, but again, it would be such a small pot of users it wouldn’t be worth it for anything but maybe a spy agency targeting a competing government’s leader. And something like that would be noticed long before it would affect the average user.
So, I guess how paranoid are you. If you’re paranoid enough about remote access to your biometric based logins after that, then you shouldn’t use a phone at all. But again, a bad or reused and compromised password is exponentially more of a weak link.
Makes sense ! I didn’t know exactly how it worked.
Short answer, yes, but depends om the importance of the app or service. Different log ins have all their + and - in question of security. Most security is by physical tokens but a longer Passphrase with 2FA isn’t less secure. Biometric datas can be leaked, eg. A fingerprint logging on a Smartphone is easy duplicable with a simple Tesa strip, only somewhat more effective when also used with an infrared sensor.
















