

Feels like pretty soon we’re going to lose track of how many days in a row the top headline has been “major tech system goes down”…
I’m a climate scientist by trade. Interested in interesting things. Ecology, complexity, politics, social change, music.


Feels like pretty soon we’re going to lose track of how many days in a row the top headline has been “major tech system goes down”…


Excellent work!


I want one of those old “Intel inside” stickers but saying “bullshit inside”. Can someone knock one up in gimp or something?


Really hope this doesn’t turn into a “black guy gets punished due to a false accusation of AI use, old white guy gets away with it after freely admitting it” type situation…


I assumed ejaculate party


I have only read about him so far, haven’t read any of his works, so I can’t recommend any. I can recommend the Farsight podcast episode on him, it’s a biography from a futures studies perspective.


Cool story. Ive been reading up on the futures studies space, and there is an interesting split between assumptions of a single or most likely future (e.g. the Herman Kahn school), and assumptions of many plausible futures (e.g. the French school, Bertrand de Jouvenel). It seems like basically the old split between fate and free-will…


I don’t know how someone can think “AI CAN obscure reality …”
Obviously the fundamental truth is “AI does obscure reality …” (Often this will be inconsequential, but that doesn’t make it less true).
(Edit: especially an academic, FFS)


I did. I would still make the same point. We don’t need to make every conservative a true progressive believer. We need to see material change that makes things better for everyone (which will probably help change many conservatives view of what is OK/good).
This is not a “by any means necessary” thing, it’s a “use what levers you have access to” thing.


I dunno that changing a fox news host’s mind is the main game here…


Like a fraction of a percent of people will run their own models. It won’t influence price. Remember that coders/tech people are only a minority of users.


now they are laying of staff? What, did they blow their whole budget out?


I think there’s this belief that guardrails like this are implemented as some kind of rules that the model must follow (like, a logical constraint). They aren’t, they are just extra details added in to the context window - effectively prepended to the response (source: OpenAI’s tutorial on how to implement guardrails). There is no guarantee that it will interpret them correctly, or follow them.
Huh. Really? How is the LLM checking it? Is it writing code to check those specs, or are you just along it directly if the code matches the specs?
Absolutely agree, hence my link to the Luddite wikipedia page elsewhere in the thread.
Currently, LLMs are being used as a tool of the rich to gain more control over broader society.
I’m not trying to police individuals. Linus is acting as a spokesperson and leader of a major organisation, I’m only interested in what he does in that capacity.
For sure, there’s a cat’s-out-of-the-bag element. But that doesn’t give those of us with more ethics an excuse to act as if we don’t have them.


What I would like to see is a LLM that’s developed … with FULL traceability to sources uses,
That’s not really possible. I mean, you can list the training data, but you can’t attribute a specific output to a specific piece of training data, because all of the training data influences all of the weights. It’s not possible to know which training data influenced which weights and how, because that data is not retained (and it would be massive and difficult to interpret if it was -on the order of weights × number of training context windows, and the weights alone are already terabytes)


Why is it an entirely different conversation? Or rather, why do you think that this conversation is not what the AI-opposition are concerned about? (At least some of us are)
By analogy, many of us leaped in to social media 20 years ago. 15+ years later, there was wide recognition that the new technology brought with it a shitload of undesirable outcomes that were completely unpredictable at the outset. The same can be said of fossil fuel use, as well as factory automation. Why would you not take lessons from those? Especially given what you know about the arseholes running the GenAI companies?
At this point I’d be fine if they stopped after switching it off.